If you’re considering using birth control to (a) avoid pregnancy and/or (b) manage perimenopause and menopause symptoms, which birth control method would you use?
How about the one most OB/GYNs choose for themselves?
Pretty overwhelmingly, women’s health care providers choose the IUD as their preferred family planning method. It’s also a popular choice for docs prescribing solutions for managing heavy bleeding and irregular periods in perimenopause.
We thought it was worth taking a closer look at the tiny little T that can do so much.
An IUD or intrauterine device is a small, T-shaped piece of flexible plastic that is threaded up through the vagina and into the uterus (hence “intrauterine”). Once placed, they can remain for years, effectively preventing pregnancy without impacting future fertility. IUDs for perimenopause and menopause symptoms have also become popular, and often effective, treatments.
Copper IUDs (ParaGard) are wrapped in a bit of copper and rely on sperm’s dislike of that metal to repel sperm away from an egg. Generally, copper IUDs contain no hormones and are not particularly useful for managing peri/menopause symptoms. In fact, they tend to make periods slightly heavier.
Hormonal IUDs (Mirena, Kyleena, Liletta) use a synthetic hormone to prevent pregnancy. These may be more useful for the midlife crowd, and taking estrogen along with Mirena is increasing in popularity as a treatment for symptom relief.
For women generally, the hormonal IUD is a good option for family planning and managing periods.
With a 99 percent effectiveness rate, they’re highly effective at preventing pregnancy (the Pill weighs in at around 93 percent). Considering perimenopausal women have the second-highest rate of unintended pregnancy (after teens), that can be a real benefit.
They don’t require “perfect use” from the woman. Unlike the Pill, you don’t have to remember to take them, and unlike condoms, you really can’t be caught without.
They can make periods lighter, reduce cramps, have few or no side effects, and last for years. For these reasons, hormonal IUDs for perimenopause symptoms are often the most common.
Our own ob/gyn Director of Health, Dr. Rebecca Dunsmoor-Su, is an advocate of the hormonal IUD Mirena® for women in midlife, so we asked her to explain the benefits and any risks.
Note: Dr. Rebecca particularly likes and recommends the Mirena® because it has been on the market the longest, so we asked her specifically about that brand of IUD. This information may also pertain to similar devices; however, be aware that the information below is based on the Mirena.
Dr. Rebecca: Mirena is an intrauterine device that contains levonorgestrel (a progesterone). It was originally designed for, and is used mostly for, birth control. It provides highly successful birth control for 5-7 years.
It works by placing progesterone directly into the uterus. Progesterone's effect is multiple in that place:
Dr. Rebecca: It is placed during a doctor visit and stays in place for 5-7 years, so for ease of use, it cannot be beat. It has less impact than pills on your systemic hormones, which tend to continue to do "their own thing" while the Mirena is in. In terms of efficacy, it is one of the best, as it does not rely on the human factor, and you can't forget to use it! It doesn't prevent STDs, so if you are with a new partner or have multiple partners. Quick menopause tip: condoms are still recommended.
Dr. Rebecca: In perimenopause, cycles can get more irregular, with bleeding occurring less frequently. When this happens, periods can be heavy and crampy in menopause. The Mirena keeps the uterine lining thin, so periods get much lighter and less painful and easier to manage, without having to use systemic hormonal manipulation to achieve this.
Also, it’s good protection for the uterine lining (prevents the tissue build up that can lead to endometrial cancer), so if a woman needs estrogen to ease or get rid of hot flashes and sleep disruption, she doesn't need to take oral progesterone if a Mirena is in place, providing the Mirena has been there less than 7 years and is still working.
Dr. Rebecca: It works for 5-7 years, and is safe to leave in that long. It doesn’t hurt you to leave it longer, but it no longer works as birth control or to suppress menstruation, and will no longer protect the lining if you are taking estrogen.
Are there side effects? If using Mirena for menopause, when should it be removed?
Dr. Rebecca: There is discomfort with placement and removal.
People are often concerned about infections, as they remember reports from decades ago about different IUDs. With the Mirena, there is a small risk of infection when it is inserted and removed (these are rare occurrences), but once in, it actually thickens the protective cervical mucus and reduces the likelihood of infections travelling up to the pelvis.
Many women see irregular bleeding or spotting over the first 3-6 months after the device is implanted, which resolves.
While there are reports on the Internet of weight gain, in fact, studies show weight gain is not a side effect of the IUD because, remember, it results in very low hormones being circulated systemically.
Dr. Rebecca: Most women are good candidates; only women with a history of allergic reaction to levonorgestrel, who have a current pelvic infection, or who have a uterine anomaly are not good candidates.
Unlike estrogen, progesterone is generally considered safe for women who have blood clot risk, and as the Mirena is very low dose, it’s even safer.
Use of Mirena for women with a history or high risk of breast cancer is generally, but not always, discouraged, so have a good conversation with your doctor about the benefits and risks.
If want an expert's perspective if Mirena is right for you, schedule a telehealth visit with a Gennev board-certified OB/GYN.
Dr. Rebecca: Yes. The Mirena can easily be removed by a medical professional, if the woman is more comfortable without it, but there’s no additional health risk of leaving it in, even after full menopause is achieved. And often it can be the source of progesterone if you need to use estrogen during the early years of menopause.
Dr. Rebecca: At the doctor's office, the IUD is placed through the cervix. You may feel crampy for a few minutes, but taking some Ibuprofen before the procedure can help with that. Implanting the Mirena takes 5-10 minutes and is almost always covered by insurance.
Dr. Rebecca: Bleeding can be irregular for up to 6 months, and this is normal. You should talk to your doctor if you have severe pain, high fevers, or significant discharge from the vagina. Rarely, the IUD can fall out (expel), but generally you will notice, as you will see it come out.
Dr. Rebecca: No, it does not, as it provides progesterone only. If you are having these symptoms, vaginal estrogen would be recommended.
Dr. Rebecca: No, the strings are soft and typically tuck behind the cervix. If a partner does feel something, your gynecologist can trim the strings short. Intercourse will not dislodge it. The only times I’ve seen them dislodged are when folks use menstrual cups and accidentally grab the strings when reaching up to remove the cup.
If you're in perimenopause and experiencing heavy bleeding, and/or you need an effective birth control method, a hormonal IUD such as the Mirena may be a good, safe option for you. As ever, check with your doctor to discuss any risk factors you may have.
Our Care Coordinator Kimberly is here to help! Schedule a 15-minute complimentary call with her and share your story. She'll guide you to the next best steps for you.SCHEDULE MY CALL